Our southern border encompasses 2,100 miles, and this includes some mountain ranges. Why President Bush thinks that putting up a 700 mile fence that is half the length of the border is going to help solve the illegal immigration problem, I have no idea. Another issue is that apparently there is no money to build this fence. So, while the president has signed into being the Secure Fence Act of 2006, it appears at least at this point that the bill is simply words on paper. Without funding I do not see how it is going to be built.
However, putting aside the fact that there is most likely no money to build this fence, which is not surprising when you consider the amount of money that is going into the Iraq War, will this fence keep out illegal immigrants? I don't believe so. Fences can be climbed, cut through with wire cutters or saws, and crawled under, maybe not easily but it is still possible. All you have to do is watch a dog who wants to get out of his yard dig a hole underneath the fence and wiggle out, and you'll see what I mean. If someone is determined to get into the United States illegally, they are going to find a way, fence or no fence.
Another problem is the fact the fence is not going to cover the entire width of the border, there are still going to be 700 miles of open border for illegals to go through. What is to stop them from going around the fence? Other than the border patrol which is overworked as it is, and not a guarantee because they cannot be everywhere at once, nothing.
There are even further problems with this plan though, which consist of the fact that there has been an increase in migrant deaths since 1995, which is around the time the US government began cracking down hard through the border patrol. 3,000 immigrants have lost their lives in remote parts of the Southwest since 1995. Migrants who are already desperate to find a better way of life in the United States, are going to become even more so with this fence, if it is built. The fence is not going to stop them, and it is not just the male migrants who have been dying, and who are going to die, but women and children.
While I have heard it said in the media that the President of Mexico encourages poor Mexicans to go illegally to the United States for jobs, and I disagree with this policy if he does do so, I also think the fence sends a wrong message. The message is “stay out, we don't need you, and we don't want to work with you.” I think that is cutting our noses off despite our faces. While I do not condone illegal immigration, I understand the reasons behind it. There is a demand for the services of migrants in this country, and they do produce, purchase goods here, and some even pay taxes, so there is a benefit to their being here. To send a message saying in effect, “go home, we don't need you, and anyone else don't bother coming,” could be the death knell to our economy in the longterm.
And there is a final problem that is rarely if ever addressed and that is the indigenous populations which live on both sides of the border. A fence going up is going to restrict their abilities to get to sacred grounds to perform ceremonies, and access to relatives which live on the opposite border. From what I can see, little if any input was requested from Indian tribes as to what the impact of such a fence might be on them. Nor does anyone in our government appear to be trying to make sure that treaties are not being broken. While there has been talk of an “indigenous card” for Natives, I do not see this happening anytime soon. Also, how is it determined who gets a card, and who does not? Mandatory genetic testing? That raises some real red flags for me, discrimination is alive and well, and while I personally would not have a problem with being tested, I could see this being used to discriminate.
I personally think this is just one more way for President Bush to grandstand, and try and take people's minds off of the fact that he has lied to the citizens of this country on more than one occasion, is bungling the Iraq war, and doesn't really know what he is doing, and so is making it up as he goes along. I agree we need to protect our southern border, but signing a bill for a border fence that isn't going to work, is going to foster ill will among our international neighbors, our Indigenous nations, our legal international citizens, and for which the money does not exist to build it, is not the way to stop illegal immigration. It only creates more problems for which we must then find further solutions, and we have enough of those already without adding more.